

This summer marked the return of two of my favorite entertainment franchises of all time: Indiana Jones and The X-Files. Even though both films opened to mixed reviews, I was very excited to see the current series installments, and finally got around to doing so last week. I first took in a late night screening of Dr. Jones and company with K-Dogg, as I assumed it was probably on its last big-screen legs, since it came out in May. I really didn’t have a lot of prior knowledge about the plot and figured I’d be fine with watching Harrison Ford and Shia LaBeouf trapsing around jungles, dodging bad guys and solving clues in search of some mysterious treasure. I wish I’d had a little prior knowledge. Not sure what George Lucas was thinking, maybe he’s an X-Files fan too, but he had the good doctor tracking down mystical alien skulls in the amazon rain forest, eluding lame CGI monkeys (part of a ridiculous, Tarzanesque rope swinging sequence for Shia LaBeouf) and eventullay winding up in an alien chamber that turns out to be a spacecraft of some kind. What? What happened to punching Nazis in the face and hunting for biblical treasures? What happened to awesome booby traps and using supreme historical knowledge to uncover hidden catacombs? I’m all for the fact that Indiana Jones does have some fantastical elements to it - heavenly ghouls, melting faces and archaic guardian knights - but aliens? The kind from outer space? Really? It just didn’t work for me. From the get-go something was off. The lighting in the opening sequence was almost washed out, Ford’s comedic timing and delivery weren’t very crisp, Cate Blanchette’s acting prowess was completely wasted and LaBeouf’s 50s-greaser persona was overembelished. It all felt forced and really only delivered in the disappointment category. For the record, I wasn’t someone who felt that the franchise should have been left alone. In fact, I think it’s the perfect type of series that can sustain additions as long as they’re consistent with what has already been done. The third movie with Sean Connerey is a perfect example of that guideline. I’m not trying to completely destroy the movie either; it did have a couple of really well done, classic Indiana Jones chase scenes that honored the glory of the preceding films and Harrison Ford was physically up to the task and looked the part in every way - something that was of concern for fans before opening day. Be that as it may, it wasn’t enough to carry the movie. Maybe this was just a segue movie for the studio to transition LaBeouf into the starring role in order to perpetuate the Jones legacy (a terrible idea) and maybe Indianapolis LaBeouf (a rogue CIA agent) and the Curse of the Internet Hackers is just around the corner, poised to make $400 million. If so, the studio can laugh in my face, but I just felt like there were lofty expectations for such a storied franchise I happen to love and it just fell short. Really short. Not saying I wouldn’t watch the fake Shia-movie mentioned above, but I’d probably wait for it to come on HBO.
Upon entering into a Sunday matinee of X-Files 2 with Nealworld I had a little bit to go on: mysterious killings, weird priest, stand alone-non conspiracy plot line and most critics thought it sucked. I thought the plotline sounded promising and all the negative reviews in the world couldn’t keep me away from the movie I wanted to see most in 2008. That’s right, I was looking forward to The X-Files 2 more than Batman. What can I say: I love the show and the thought of a Mulder and Scully reunion dwarfed all other cinematic debuts. It’s just how I’m living. Anyway, the opening credits instantly sparked fond memories of my beloved show and when the siganture music played I was right back into that supernatural world and ready to see Duchovny and Anderson bring it all together for me. Before I go any further I think I need to explain that I really love the X-Files, especially the characters of Mulder and Scully. I would watch a movie about them taking a nice afternoon bike ride together followed up with Fox reading to Dana aloud from whatever is laying around. Perhaps it’s even the phone book - whatever. I’ll watch him read to her from the phone book. I feel it’s important for you to be aware of my bias as you read the rest of this. Overall, I felt the movie was good - not great, but good. The plotline was solid and had the right balance between legitimate FBI case and traditional X-Files mysticism, and Duchovny and Anderson had their usual perfect chemistry. I was actually a little surprised coming out of the theater that the movie had been so poorly received; I certainly didn’t see any glaring problems with the film and found it to be quite entertaining. In fact, the only real problem was with the script. There wasn’t enough backstory about what Mulder had been doing since his departure from the bureau and for the first half of the movie it was completely unclear as to the status of his relationship with Scully. Not sure why that was so ambiguous, but it felt like the writers were in a hurry to just get Mulder and Scully back to working for the FBI so they could progress the primary storyline, so more personal issues were glossed over or resolved too quickly. I really liked the struggle between faith and personal strength that Scully went through - Gillian Anderson is such a great actress, she should really be cast in more movies - I just wish it had been used to tie Mulder and Scully together rather than serve as a weak device to temporarily separate them. The supporting cast was good, with the exception of a disappointing Xzibit, and some familiar faces provided nice cameos along the way. I felt it was a solid sequel that X-Files fans will enjoy and those with no ties to the show should also find entertaining. Plus, it’s just good to see Mulder and Scully back in action. Don’t see myself getting tired of that.
Indiana Jones vs. Mulder & Scully. Battle of the movie gaints. When the smoke clears, The X-Files is the clear winner of the cinematic brawl (despite what box office totals will tell you) and presides as the reigning champion of revived franchises. America’s favorite FBI agents stand tall and remind Dr. Jones that they’ve got way more experience with the paranormal and that perhaps he should leave alien encounters to the experts.
-John